HtRaB Ch 10: Criticizing a Book Fairly

 This chapter actually had some amount of new content! More about why critique is important than how to critique (have reasons. That's like 90% of the how). I like that Adler makes sure to emphasize that even great books aren't above criticism. He emphasizes that you need to make sure you understand a book before you critique it, otherwise you'll be inane and/or impudent.

Don't upset Mr. Garvey

He talks about how all critique and disagreement should be with the goal of reaching some kind of understanding and resolution. Don't just get into a reddit slap-fight with the author. Argue to better understand what's going on.

Finally, he emphasizes one of my favorite classics maxims: Anyone can learn enough to give good critiques if they put in the effort.

Go learn stuff!